Email Accessibility Metrics: Advanced Analysis

Advanced analysis techniques for measuring email accessibility performance.

SpamBarometer Team
April 6, 2025
7 min read

Ensuring accessibility is a critical aspect of any successful email marketing campaign. This comprehensive guide dives into advanced analysis techniques and metrics for measuring and optimizing email accessibility performance. We'll cover industry best practices, step-by-step implementation guides, real-world examples, and common pitfalls to avoid. By the end, you'll have a thorough understanding of how to create emails that are accessible to all users, driving better engagement and conversion rates.

Understanding Email Accessibility Standards

Before diving into advanced analysis, it's important to have a solid grasp of the various accessibility standards and guidelines that apply to email. The most widely recognized standards include:

  • Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1
  • Section 508 of the Rehabilitation Act
  • Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA)

These standards provide a framework for creating emails that are perceivable, operable, understandable, and robust for users with disabilities. Some key considerations include:

  • Providing alternative text for images
  • Using sufficient color contrast
  • Ensuring proper heading structure
  • Making links and buttons keyboard accessible

Accessibility Metrics Overview

To effectively measure and optimize email accessibility, you need to track the right metrics. Some key accessibility metrics include:

Accessibility Score

An overall score (usually 0-100) that indicates how well your email adheres to accessibility guidelines. Tools like Litmus and Email on Acid provide automated accessibility scores.

Color Contrast Ratio

Measures the difference in luminance between foreground (text) and background colors. A minimum contrast ratio of 4.5:1 is required for normal text and 3:1 for large text (18pt or 14pt bold).

Diagram 1
Diagram 1
The above diagram illustrates how color contrast affects email readability for users with visual impairments. It should show examples of good and bad color contrast, along with their corresponding contrast ratios.

Automated Accessibility Testing

Manually auditing every email for accessibility can be time-consuming and prone to human error. That's where automated testing tools come in. Some popular options include:

Tool Description
Litmus Provides an automated accessibility check as part of its email previewing and testing suite. Identifies issues with color contrast, missing alt text, improper heading structure, and more.
Email on Acid Offers a similar accessibility testing feature, with a detailed report highlighting areas for improvement and providing actionable recommendations.
WAVE A free web accessibility evaluation tool that can also be used to test HTML email code. Provides visual feedback and detailed information about accessibility errors and alerts.

While automated tools are a great starting point, they shouldn't be relied upon exclusively. Manual testing and user feedback are still critical for catching issues that automated tools may miss.

Manual Accessibility Auditing

To supplement automated testing, it's important to perform regular manual accessibility audits. This involves carefully reviewing your emails from the perspective of users with various disabilities and assistive technologies. Some key areas to focus on include:

Ensure that your email uses a logical heading structure (H1-H6) to convey the content hierarchy. This makes it easier for screen reader users to navigate and understand the email's content.

<h1>Main Heading</h1>
<h2>Subheading</h2> 
<h3>Section Heading</h3>

All informative images should have descriptive alternative text that conveys the image's content and purpose. Decorative images should have empty alt attributes (alt="").

<img src="product.jpg" alt="Blue running shoes with white soles">
<img src="divider.jpg" alt="">

Ensure that all interactive elements (links, buttons, form controls) can be accessed and activated using only a keyboard. This is critical for users who cannot use a mouse or other pointing device.

<a href="#" class="btn">Buy Now</a>
<button type="button">Learn More</button>
Diagram 2
Diagram 2
The above diagram should illustrate the process of manually auditing an email for accessibility, highlighting the key areas to focus on (headings, alt text, keyboard access) and showing examples of accessible vs. inaccessible code.

Tracking Engagement Metrics by Assistive Technology

To get a true sense of how accessible your emails are, it's important to track engagement metrics segmented by assistive technology usage. Some key metrics to monitor include:

  • Open rates - The percentage of subscribers using assistive technologies who opened your email
  • Click-through rates - The percentage of assistive technology users who clicked a link in your email
  • Conversion rates - The percentage of assistive technology users who completed a desired action (purchase, signup, etc.)

By comparing these metrics to your overall engagement rates, you can identify accessibility gaps and areas for improvement. For example:

If your overall click-through rate is 5% but only 1% for screen reader users, that indicates a potential issue with your email's keyboard accessibility or link text.

Accessibility Performance Dashboards

To make accessibility data more actionable, consider creating dashboards that visualize key metrics and trends over time. Some examples include:

Diagram 3
Diagram 3
This diagram should show a sample accessibility performance dashboard, with widgets displaying metrics like accessibility score, color contrast ratio, engagement rates by assistive technology, and trend lines over time.

Dashboards make it easy to spot issues and track progress as you work to improve your email accessibility. They can also be shared with stakeholders to demonstrate the impact of accessibility initiatives.

User Testing with People with Disabilities

While automated tools and manual audits are valuable, the best way to truly understand the accessibility of your emails is to test them with real users who have disabilities. This can involve:

  • Recruiting users with a range of disabilities (visual, auditory, motor, cognitive) to test your emails
  • Conducting moderated usability testing sessions to observe how users interact with your emails using assistive technologies
  • Gathering feedback on pain points, areas for improvement, and overall user experience

Pro tip: Partner with disability advocacy organizations or accessibility consultancies to recruit diverse user testers and ensure your testing process is inclusive and ethical.

Diagram 4
Diagram 4
This diagram should illustrate the user testing process, showing a diverse group of users with disabilities interacting with an email using various assistive technologies (screen readers, screen magnifiers, voice controls, etc.)

Continuous Accessibility Improvement

Accessibility is not a one-time fix, but an ongoing process of continuous improvement. To ensure your emails remain accessible over time, consider implementing:

  • Accessibility training for email marketers, designers, and developers
  • Accessibility checkpoints in your email creation workflow
  • Regular accessibility audits and user testing
  • Accessibility champions on your team to drive initiatives and best practices
Accessibility Progress
Use the progress bar above to track and visualize your team's accessibility improvement efforts over time.

Case Studies and Success Stories

To inspire your own accessibility initiatives, look to case studies and success stories from other organizations. Some examples:

Litmus Sees 500% Increase in Alt Text Adoption

After implementing accessibility best practices and training for their email team, Litmus saw a 500% increase in alternative text usage on images, improving the experience for screen reader users.

Campaign Monitor Boosts Click-Through Rates by 20%

By optimizing color contrast and link text in their emails, Campaign Monitor saw a 20% increase in click-through rates from users with visual impairments.

Use these stories as motivation and proof of the tangible benefits of prioritizing email accessibility.

Diagram 5
Diagram 5
This final diagram should be an inspirational visualization of the positive impact of email accessibility, showing happy diverse users engaging with an accessible email and statistics like increased open rates, click-through rates, and conversions.

Conclusion and Next Steps

By implementing the advanced analysis techniques and best practices covered in this guide, you'll be well on your way to creating emails that are truly accessible to all users. Remember, accessibility is an ongoing journey - not a destination. Keep testing, iterating, and striving for continuous improvement. Your users (and your bottom line) will thank you.

Next steps:

  1. Audit your current emails for accessibility issues
  2. Implement automated and manual testing processes
  3. Create accessibility dashboards to track key metrics
  4. Conduct user testing with people with disabilities
  5. Provide accessibility training for your team
  6. Celebrate your successes and share lessons learned

Happy accessible emailing!

Was this guide helpful?
Need More Help?

Our team of email deliverability experts is available to help you implement these best practices.

Contact Us